Kadner: State ruling on Oak Forest stuns county health officials
Tuesday, March 22, 2011
by Phil Kadner
In a stunning decision, a state review board on Monday told Cook County it cannot close Oak Forest Hospital.
I say the decision is stunning because it
appears the Cook County Health and Hospital system — which operates Oak
Forest, Stroger and Provident hospitals — had no contingency plan in
place to keep the hospital open.
“In the coming days, the system will explore
possible contingencies as a result of today’s vote,” Bill Foley, chief
executive of the county health system, stated in a news release.
It is likely Cook County will appeal the board’s
ruling, technically known as an “intent to deny,” at the board’s May 10
hearing. Cook County has six months to appeal the board’s decision.
As part of a five-year strategic plan, Cook
County has proposed replacing Oak Forest Hospital with a regional health
center offering various medical specialties and some outpatient
surgeries. The proposal has been compared to intermediate care clinics
operated by private hospitals in the Southland.
But prior to Monday’s board meeting, the staff of
the Illinois Health Facilities and Services Review Board had
recommended against closing Oak Forest, contending that the resulting
patient demand could not be handled by nearby hospitals.
The state board must, by law, sign off on plans
to open any new hospitals or close existing ones. Oak Forest Hospital
had been scheduled to close June 1.
Lucio Guerrero, spokesman for the Cook County
Health and Hospitals System, said the agency’s budget had been cut by 20
percent and did not include funds to keep Oak Forest Hospital open.
“I can’t tell you yet how we are going to fund the hospital or how much,” Guerrero stated in an e-mail.
State health officials have questioned where poor
people would go for health care until 2015, when Cook County planned to
have its new regional health care clinic up and running, and seemed
skeptical about whether the county would follow through once the
hospital was closed.
“We can’t ramp up the outpatient side and have the hospital operating as is,” Guerrero stated.
The hospital “as is” is a gutted version of its
former self because Cook County has been cutting its budget and programs
The hospital campus sits on 340 acres and
includes 41 buildings that offer more than 1 million square feet of
space. Most of the buildings sit empty now.
There’s a pauper’s cemetery, where the poor were
once buried in pine boxes on top of each other. There are unused
greenhouses, which once grew flowers and plants to decorate the
There’s a Catholic chapel, a Protestant chapel
and a Jewish synagogue, built in 1911 and 1912. The poor of Cook County
once worked a farm on the property.
The county has plans to sell some of the property, which would be prime commercial real estate once the economy rebounds.
Tya Robinson-May, a Harvey resident and Cook
County nurse who has been organizing protests against the hospital
closing, responded to the health board’s vote by shouting, “It’s a
She’s aware that Cook County plans to ask the
state board to reconsider its decision, “but at least we’ve bought a
little more time to rally public support and get thousands more people
behind our effort to save the hospital,” she said.
I’m grateful the state board slowed down the
process of closing Oak Forest Hospital and is now casting a critical eye
on Cook County’s plans.
For more than a year, county health officials
have presented their plan to close the hospital as if there was no
viable alternative. While many public meetings and hearings were held on
the plan, keeping the hospital open was never considered a realistic
And Cook County has made it clear that Stroger Hospital, serving the needs of Chicago’s poor, is its top priority.
I felt the people of the south suburbs were deserving of equal treatment.
Now, the state is forcing Cook County to justify its plans to close Oak Forest Hospital, and I think that’s a good thing.
The county must address the health care needs of the south suburbs in a timely fashion that demonstrates a sense of urgency.
“I will step up my efforts to keep that half-cent sales tax Cook County is planning to eliminate,” Robinson-May said.
I told her the county board wasn’t likely to reverse its position on the sales tax rollback.
“You didn’t think it was possible to save Oak Forest Hospital, either,” she said.
She’s right about that.