Suffredin- An Advocate for All of Us  
 

Accountability
Forest Preserves
Public Safety
Cook County Budget
Forest Pres. Budget
Property Tax Appeal
Health & Hospitals
Land Bank Authority
Policy Resolutions
Unsung Heroine

 

   
 
   
   
 
   
     
  Office phone numbers:  
   
 
 

Search current and proposed Cook County Legislation in Larry's exclusive legislative library.

   
 

The Cook County Code of Ordinances are the current laws of Cook County.

   
  The Cook County Forest Preserve District maintains over 70 miles of bicycle trails.
   
     
     
     



Berrios' analysts used Zillow, other shortcuts in assessing property values, documents show

Friday, July 13, 2018
Chicago Tribune
by Hal Dardick

Berrios' analysts used Zillow, other shortcuts in assessing property values, documents show

Newly released court documents show that analysts working for Cook County Assessor Joseph Berrios often changed home values produced by the office’s computer model, a sign of shortcomings in the system that made the property tax system unfair to less-affluent homeowners.

More than a fifth of home values were adjusted during “hand reviews,” with assessment analysts sometimes relying on websites such as Zillow or Trulia to determine a home’s characteristics, Berrios’ director of residential valuations said under oath.

In addition, aides sometimes switched the values of similar homes in entire neighborhoods “depending on where our level of assessment is or where we want to be,” in the words of one analyst. And Berrios workers removed so-called outliers — homes that fall outside neighborhood patterns — from an initial computer analysis without a set of specific guidelines to determine which should be taken out of the equation.

The revelations are contained in court documents stemming from a lawsuit the Chicago Tribune filed as it was reporting on “The Tax Divide.” The investigation found that the assessor’s home values in affluent neighborhoods often were too low, and those in economically struggling areas often were too high — resulting in an unfair shift of the tax burden from the wealthy to the less affluent.

Read the Chicago Tribune's "Tax Divide" series »

Berrios’ office denied an open records request for documents and spreadsheets related to hand reviews and commercial assessments. The Tribune went to court, saying the office had no right to withhold the documents under Illinois law. Last month, an Illinois appeals court upheld a lower court ruling ordering the documents released.

As Berrios now mulls whether to take the issue to the Illinois Supreme Court, the appeals court unsealed previously unavailable files associated with the case.

Among them is an August 2016 deposition by Alfonso Sarro, Berrios’ director of residential valuations. Sarro testified that “the function of the assessor’s office is to value all property uniformly and fairly for ... real estate tax purposes.” But he went on to describe a process that sometimes veered from industry standards.

Sarro testified that “between 20 and 25 percent (of) values are actually changed by hand,” with analysts determining that the computer model used to value the properties in the first place got it wrong.

Expert Christopher Berry called that “an incredibly high number.” A rule of thumb in the assessment industry is that hand reviews should change only 1 to 2 percent of the property values calculated by the computer and only in cases where there is “a really good and explicit reason,” he said.

Other revelations in Sarro’s deposition include:

— Assessor’s analysts followed no “fixed set of guidelines” in determining so-called outliers — homes with values that skew the model because they’re inconsistent with neighborhood patterns, like a large mansion built amid a block full of bungalows.

“There are usually standards involved,” and entire sections of assessment textbooks lay them out, said Berry, a University of Chicago professor who helped design a new model for Berrios’ office that was never fully implemented.

— When doing the hand-check process, analysts sometimes relied on data from internet sites like Zillow or Trulia “for insight into home characteristics” — such as square footage and number of rooms — that can affect values. Berry said that’s problematic. “If they are doing that for one set of homes and not others, that’s going to introduce nonuniformity into the process,” he said.

— After the hand reviews were done, supervisors in the assessor’s office then looked at the resulting values for entire neighborhoods and determined whether they might be too low or too high for a particular type of property, such as townhouses. If that was so, they made a percentage adjustment to all townhouses in that neighborhood. Berry said that showed a lack of faith in the model used to value the properties in the first place.

All those steps leave the impression of a “seat-of-the-pants approach, because they haven’t shown us how they conduct this process,” Berry said. And making so many changes after running the data through the computer system could introduce a lack of uniformity that makes the system less fair, he said.

MORE COVERAGE: Berrios tweaks formula; home assessments rise on North Side, fall on South Side »

“The equation exists for a reason, and that reason is to ensure fairness,” said Berry, who added that Berrios should release all the formulas, data, documents and results involved in the assessment process.

Berrios’ office did not respond to multiple requests for comment this week. Berrios lost the March Democratic primary to asset manager Fritz Kaegi, who pledged to make assessment models and data public and also address flaws the series identified. Kaegi faces Republican Joseph Paglia, who has yet to report formation of a campaign committee, in the November general election.

Also included in the recently released lawsuit documents is a deposition of Mark Dwyer, the former director of commercial valuations in the assessor’s office, who also explained a process that could result in some properties being treated differently from others.

Dwyer testified that “capitalization rates” — figures used to determine a commercial property’s income potential that in turn sets its value — “are purely a matter of opinion by the analyst” but must fall within a range determined by Thomas Jaconetty, a top aide to Berrios.

In some cases, analysts turned to Zillow to determine potential rents for commercial properties, Dwyer said. In others they relied on newspapers or business magazines to discover some commercial sales data, he added.

As part of the series, the Tribune later collaborated with ProPublica Illinois and found that commercial and industrial properties were underassessed, which pushed more of the tax burden onto the backs of homeowners. The series also found that the assessor’s estimates were deeply unfair, punishing small businesses and giving breaks to the owners of more expensive properties.

For a long time, the assessor was dismissive of “The Tax Divide” and its findings. After the series documented problems with residential assessments, County Board President Toni Preckwinkle commissioned an independent study. The Civic Consulting Alliance was tasked with looking at residential assessments and confirmed the series’ work.

That study identified hand reviews as one of the reasons the system unfairly shifted the tax burden, saying they introduced “systematic bias” to the process. More than 92 percent of initial assessments were changed as a result of hand reviews and other adjustments, the study found.

When the study came out, Berrios vowed to fix the problem, working with the Consulting Alliance and Tyler Technologies, the firm the county has hired to update its property taxation computer systems. An assessor’s news release issued last month stated that a new model is in place that resulted in “a significant reduction in the number of necessary hand checks.” But Berrios has not released the model or data fed into it, making the claim difficult to assess.

Jaconetty, the deputy assessor, previously defended the assessment model that was used, saying homeowners would be relieved to know that the assessor is not relying solely on the “purity of mathematics.”

“Would they be as concerned about their assessments being based purely on math and driven by equations?” he asked. “Or would they feel better knowing there was a human being involved?”

Berry, however, said the human aspect might not inspire confidence in a system that many people already mistrust.

“Given this office and its long history of corruption and troubles, I don’t think people will be reassured that they are going in there and having someone change those numbers,” he added.

hdardick@chicagotribune.com



Recent Headlines

Editorial: What happened to the elk?
Friday, August 10, 2018
Chicago Tribune

Wells Fargo to offer $15,000 grants to potential Cook County homebuyers
Thursday, August 09, 2018
Chicago Tribune

Suit alleges Cook County detainees secretly monitored in bathrooms in holding cells at courthouses
Wednesday, August 08, 2018
Chicago Tribune

Half the elk at Busse Woods died last year, and officials aren’t sure why
Tuesday, August 07, 2018
Chicago Tribune

A letter from Dr. Jay Shannon regarding gun violence and Stroger Hospital
Tuesday, August 07, 2018
Special to suffredin.org

As Evanston adapts to minimum wage hike, nearby towns say they have no plan to join in
Tuesday, August 07, 2018
Chicago Tribune

Lawsuit could blast a $250 million hole in county budget
Monday, August 06, 2018
Crain's Chicago Business

Pappas: Automatic refunds of $19.5 million going to 53,000 homeowners because of property tax cuts
Monday, August 06, 2018
Special to suffredin.org

Thousands of Cook County homeowners to receive property tax refunds
Monday, August 06, 2018
Chicago Sun-Times

Cook County Board Adopts Resolution Concerned With Foxconn Impacts
Thursday, August 02, 2018
Journal and Topics Media Group

FBI: Ex-employee alleges Dorothy Brown picked up cash payoffs at bagman's home
Thursday, August 02, 2018
Chicago Tribune

Demolition of MWRD dam to clear way for fish and recreation
Wednesday, August 01, 2018
Special to suffredin.org

EXCLUSIVE: Sheriff Tom Dart to pair inmates with pet dogs
Wednesday, August 01, 2018
Chicago Sun-Times

County Minimum Wage, Sick Time Advisory Questions Approved for November Ballot
Wednesday, August 01, 2018
Journal and Topics Media Group

Editorial: Berrios and Kaegi: What a new assessor can and can't fix
Thursday, July 26, 2018
Chicago Tribune

Your Personal Data May Be Exposed in Cook County Traffic Records
Wednesday, July 25, 2018
CBS Chicago

Garcia avoids public tiff with Preckwinkle, delays plan for county revenue forecasting commission
Wednesday, July 25, 2018
Chicago Tribune

Cook County TIF districts bring in $1 billion
Tuesday, July 24, 2018
Chicago Sun-Times

Cook County board moves to prevent repeat of pop tax fiasco
Friday, July 20, 2018
Crain's Chicago Business

Cook County forest worker was going 76 mph in 30 mph zone, had THC in system during fatal crash while on job: prosecutors
Thursday, July 19, 2018
Chicago Tribune

all news items

Paid for by Larry Suffredin and not at taxpayer expense. A Haymarket Production.
^ TOP